20.06.2008 12:25:00
|
TCI and 3G Capital Send Letter to CSX Shareholders
The Children’s Investment Fund Management (UK)
LLP ("TCI”) and 3G
Capital Partners, Ltd. ("3G”)
today sent the following letter to shareholders of CSX Corp. (NYSE: CSX).
The full text of the letter follows:
June 20, 2008
Dear Fellow CSX Shareholder,
Earlier this week, RiskMetrics Group - ISS Governance Services, the
leading independent proxy voting advisory and corporate governance
services firm ("ISS”),
recommended that CSX shareholders vote to elect four of the five
candidates nominated by TCI/3G for election to the board of directors of
CSX Corporation. Noting that "this [proxy]
fight is about the makeup of the [CSX]
board” and not about who controls CSX, ISS
concluded that TCI/3G nominees Christopher Hohn, Alexandre Behring,
Gilbert Lamphere and Timothy O’Toole "either
have a strong track record in creating shareholder value and/or would
provide significant industry experience or an invaluable shareholder
perspective to the [CSX]
board.”
We agree with ISS’s conclusion, but believe
that, with his significant transportation and financial experience, Gary
L. Wilson, our fifth board nominee, also will add value to CSX boardroom
deliberations. Therefore, we urge you to vote for the election of all
five of the TCI/3G nominees by completing, signing and promptly
returning TCI/3G’s BLUE proxy card today.
ISS recognizes TCI/3G’s commitment to
CSX.
We are pleased to have the endorsement of ISS, whose subscribers include
many of the world’s largest institutional
investors and whose views on corporate governance are sought by most of
the world’s leading public companies. We also
are gratified that ISS has acknowledged our "particularly
in-depth understanding of [CSX]
and the railroad industry” –
knowledge gained through years of research and hands-on railroad
experience. In fact, in its analysis ISS stated that, "we
cannot recall an activist investor platform as detailed and nuanced as
TCI/3G’s, which to us demonstrates a
significant investment of time and resources by [TCI
and 3G] in the CSX investment thesis.”
ISS also recognized the magnitude and nature of TCI/3G’s
investment in CSX. "We note the dissidents
will have an economic stake 15x that of the incumbent board with only
their physical shares, and as such would better align the interests of
directors and shareholders,” the proxy
advisor observed, adding that, "TCI has
been economically exposed to CSX for almost 20 months, once again
reminding investors to treat a company’s cry
of hedge fund ‘short-termism’
with a fair amount of skepticism.” CSX remains "one of the underperformers
within its peer group.”
While acknowledging recent improvements in performance at CSX, ISS noted
that CSX "appears to remain one of the
underperformers within its peer group, with significant gaps remaining
between CSX and the industry leaders on margin, FCF, return and
productivity.” ISS also opined that our
concerns regarding customer service and capital spending at CSX are
legitimate. Despite CSX’s rejection of
comparisons to industry leader Canadian National, ISS found that such
benchmarking appears to have industry and analyst support. Its
conclusions regarding our analysis of performance at CSX are summarized
by ISS’s observation that, "TCI/3G
make some convincing arguments that there is substantial potential to be
realized by improving various productivity metrics at CSX, which could
lead to significant value upside.” CSX’s behavior raises corporate
governance concerns for ISS.
ISS disapproves of the incumbent board’s
decision to move the record date for determining shareholders entitled
to vote at the annual meeting, which struck ISS as "manipulative,”
and the choice of venue for the rescheduled annual meeting ("a
relatively inaccessible rail yard in New Orleans”),
implying "an inappropriate attempt to ‘game
the system’.” ISS
also shares our concern regarding the company’s
"Washington strategy,”
stating that, "we find it hard to believe
that CSX has not played a role in generating governmental interference
with respect to this proxy fight.” Finally,
ISS shares our disappointment in the board’s
continuing opposition to shareholder support for the right to call a
special meeting at any time and for any purpose, including the right to
remove and replace directors, which was approved by CSX shareholders at
last year’s annual meeting by a margin of
more than 2 to 1.
To ISS, the choice is clear:
Based on [CSX’s]
lagging operational performance and the troubling corporate governance
implications of the company’s aggressive
proxy fight defense, and the dissident nominees’
track record, skill sets and experience (as well as the numerous
additional factors detailed at length [in the
ISS report]), on balance we recommend that
CSX shareholders support four [TCI/3G]
nominees: Hohn, Behring, Lamphere and O’Toole. But, CSX has responded to the ISS voting recommendation by
attacking ISS itself.
Consider the following coverage of CSX’s
response to the ISS voting recommendation by Richard Beales in a Breaking
Views article from earlier today:
By slinging mud at [ISS’s]
analysis and judgment, CSX is again avoiding the real governance issue.
. . .
The questions CSX should be addressing are the ones [that
ISS] asked itself: Have the dissidents
showed the need for a change in the board’s
composition? And if so, are their nominees better qualified than the
incumbent directors?
In mostly answering in the affirmative, [ISS]
is not suggesting TCI and 3G are right in all their criticisms of CSX’s
governance, strategy and operations. It’s
saying that shareholders’ interests would be
better served by the injection of a few new, better qualified board
members to debate such issues and hold Ward and his management team
accountable.
CSX has scarcely addressed those questions, perhaps because the
apparent lack of hands-on railway experience or other relevant expertise
on the part of some of its long-serving directors might be hard to
defend. . . . But [ISS]
isn't in the fight. CSX executives owe shareholders a persuasive
rebuttal - if they have one - of [ISS’s]
message, not potshots at the messenger.
Time is short! CSX’s 2008
annual meeting of shareholders will be held on Wednesday, June 25.
Again, if you believe CSX cannot afford to rest on its laurels in
favorable pricing and market environments, if you believe that CSX
should strive to achieve its full operating potential, if you believe
that CSX can and should be the best railroad in America and, finally, if
you believe the board of CSX will benefit from the railroad experience
of our nominees, along with the perspectives of large shareholders who
are engaged because they have made a significant investment in CSX stock
using their own money, we urge you to join with us in electing our
five nominees to the board of directors of CSX by voting on the
BLUE TCI/3G proxy card today.
If you have any questions or need assistance in voting your shares,
please call D. F. King & Co., Inc., which is assisting TCI and 3G with
the solicitation of proxies from CSX shareholders, toll-free at
1-800-967-7635.
Our nominees pledge to work constructively and tirelessly to advance the
interests of all CSX shareholders.
We thank you for your consideration and support.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Chris Hohn
Managing Partner, TCI
/s/ Alex Behring
Managing Director, 3G Capital
About TCI
TCI is a London-based asset manager founded in 2003 which manages The
Children’s Investment Master Fund. TCI makes
long-term investments in companies globally. The management company is
authorized and regulated in the United Kingdom by the Financial Services
Authority. The majority of TCI’s profits go
to The Children’s Investment Fund Foundation,
a non-profit organization focused on improving the lives of children
living in poverty in developing countries.
About 3G
3G manages a private investment fund that invests in global equities and
special situations. 3G Fund L.P. leverages its deep industry and
operating expertise in different sectors to identify attractive,
long-duration investment opportunities.
THIS PRESS RELEASE IS FOR GENERAL INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES
NOT HAVE REGARD TO THE SPECIFIC INVESTMENT OBJECTIVE, FINANCIAL
SITUATION, SUITABILITY, OR THE PARTICULAR NEED OF ANY SPECIFIC PERSON
WHO MAY RECEIVE THIS PRESS RELEASE, AND SHOULD NOT BE TAKEN AS ADVICE ON
THE MERITS OF ANY INVESTMENT DECISION. THE VIEWS EXPRESSED HEREIN
REPRESENT THE OPINIONS OF THE CHILDREN'S INVESTMENT FUND MANAGEMENT (UK)
LLP, THE CHILDREN'S INVESTMENT FUND MANAGEMENT (CAYMAN) LTD., THE
CHILDREN'S INVESTMENT MASTER FUND, 3G CAPITAL PARTNERS LTD., 3G CAPITAL
PARTNERS, L.P., 3G FUND L.P., CHRISTOPHER HOHN, ALEXANDRE BEHRING,
GILBERT LAMPHERE, TIMOTHY O'TOOLE AND GARY WILSON (COLLECTIVELY, THE
"PARTICIPANTS"), AND ARE BASED ON PUBLICLY AVAILABLE INFORMATION WITH
RESPECT TO CSX CORPORATION.
EXCEPT FOR THE HISTORICAL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, THE MATTERS
ADDRESSED IN THIS PRESS RELEASE ARE FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS THAT
INVOLVE CERTAIN RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES. YOU SHOULD BE AWARE THAT ACTUAL
RESULTS COULD DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM THOSE CONTAINED IN THE
FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS. THE PARTICIPANTS ASSUME NO OBLIGATION TO
UPDATE THE FORWARD-LOOKING INFORMATION.
THE PARTICIPANTS RESERVE THE RIGHT TO CHANGE ANY OF THEIR OPINIONS
EXPRESSED HEREIN AT ANY TIME AS THEY DEEM APPROPRIATE. THE PARTICIPANTS
DISCLAIM ANY OBLIGATION TO UPDATE THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN.
THIS PRESS RELEASE DOES NOT RECOMMEND THE PURCHASE OR SALE OF ANY
SECURITY. THE PARTICIPANTS INCLUDE FUNDS AND ACCOUNTS THAT ARE IN THE
BUSINESS OF TRADING – BUYING AND SELLING -
PUBLIC SECURITIES. IT IS POSSIBLE THAT THERE WILL BE DEVELOPMENTS IN THE
FUTURE THAT CAUSE ONE OR MORE OF THE PARTICIPANTS FROM TIME TO TIME TO
SELL ALL OR A PORTION OF THEIR SHARES IN OPEN MARKET TRANSACTIONS OR
OTHERWISE (INCLUDING VIA SHORT SALES), BUY ADDITIONAL SHARES (IN OPEN
MARKET OR PRIVATELY NEGOTIATED TRANSACTIONS OR OTHERWISE), OR TRADE IN
OPTIONS, PUTS, CALLS OR OTHER DERIVATIVE INSTRUMENTS RELATING TO SUCH
SHARES.
ALL CSX STOCKHOLDERS ARE ADVISED TO READ THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT
AND OTHER DOCUMENTS RELATED TO THE SOLICITATION OF PROXIES BY THE
PARTICIPANTS FROM THE STOCKHOLDERS OF THE ISSUER FOR USE AT THE 2008
ANNUAL MEETING OF STOCKHOLDERS OF THE ISSUER BECAUSE THEY CONTAIN
IMPORTANT INFORMATION. THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT AND FORM OF PROXY
HAVE BEEN MAILED TO STOCKHOLDERS OF THE ISSUER AND ARE, ALONG WITH OTHER
RELEVANT DOCUMENTS, AVAILABLE AT NO CHARGE ON THE SEC'S WEB SITE AT HTTP://WWW.SEC.GOV.
IN ADDITION, THE PARTICIPANTS IN THE PROXY SOLICITATION WILL PROVIDE
COPIES OF THE DEFINITIVE PROXY STATEMENT WITHOUT CHARGE UPON REQUEST.
INFORMATION RELATING TO THE PARTICIPANTS IS CONTAINED IN THE DEFINITIVE
SCHEDULE 14A FILED BY THE PARTICIPANTS WITH THE SEC ON APRIL 28, 2008.
Der finanzen.at Ratgeber für Aktien!
Wenn Sie mehr über das Thema Aktien erfahren wollen, finden Sie in unserem Ratgeber viele interessante Artikel dazu!
Jetzt informieren!
Wenn Sie mehr über das Thema Aktien erfahren wollen, finden Sie in unserem Ratgeber viele interessante Artikel dazu!
Jetzt informieren!
JETZT DEVISEN-CFDS MIT BIS ZU HEBEL 30 HANDELN
Handeln Sie Devisen-CFDs mit kleinen Spreads. Mit nur 100 € können Sie mit der Wirkung von 3.000 Euro Kapital handeln.
82% der Kleinanlegerkonten verlieren Geld beim CFD-Handel mit diesem Anbieter. Sie sollten überlegen, ob Sie es sich leisten können, das hohe Risiko einzugehen, Ihr Geld zu verlieren.
Nachrichten zu CSX Corp.mehr Nachrichten
25.11.24 |
S&P 500-Papier CSX-Aktie: So viel Gewinn hätte eine CSX-Investition von vor 10 Jahren eingebracht (finanzen.at) | |
18.11.24 |
S&P 500-Titel CSX-Aktie: So viel hätten Anleger an einem CSX-Investment von vor 5 Jahren verdient (finanzen.at) | |
11.11.24 |
S&P 500-Papier CSX-Aktie: So viel Gewinn hätte ein Investment in CSX von vor 3 Jahren eingefahren (finanzen.at) | |
07.11.24 |
Gewinne in New York: NASDAQ 100 präsentiert sich letztendlich fester (finanzen.at) | |
07.11.24 |
NASDAQ 100-Handel aktuell: So performt der NASDAQ 100 am Donnerstagnachmittag (finanzen.at) | |
07.11.24 |
NASDAQ 100 aktuell: So steht der NASDAQ 100 mittags (finanzen.at) | |
07.11.24 |
Freundlicher Handel in New York: NASDAQ 100 zum Start des Donnerstagshandels in Grün (finanzen.at) | |
06.11.24 |
NASDAQ 100 aktuell: Zum Ende des Mittwochshandels Gewinne im NASDAQ 100 (finanzen.at) |